At H2K2, there was a guy who addressed peer-to-peer music sharing. (Later, he made a pass at me, and I apologized and said I was taken and gave him my card. Where did he go? silly.) One of the things he kept saying is that we can’t be ashamed of sharing music. We’re not stealing; from whom are we taking value? Not the people who give us the music; they still have their copy. The musicians are already being robbed blind by labels, and we need to find other ways to pay them. (Some people say live concerts, with which I heartily agree.)
[I’ve had occasion to think about similar issues from a writing standpoint at work lately, though I’m not sure how to fit this ultra-bleeding-edge kind of critique into the dead-tree-oriented work I do under the guidance of a stodgy old-school New York leftist...
The one thing I do know is that I don’t think anyone should make a living off writing memoirs and personal essays. Not anyone. Possibly people shouldn’t get paid for fiction or poetry, either. Do it in your off hours, when you’re not plumbing or teaching or farming or signing off on contracts which enrich you by exploiting the work of others (at least until the system collapses and takes the latter kind of work down too). It’s great that right now some people want to pay for this stuff, and I do exploit it, but I’m coming to think of getting paid for most writing as an unsustinable by-product of the current corporate system. This kind of writing (this kind. right here. and I extend the categorization to include anything written by Philip Lopate, Adrienne Rich, Barbara Kingsolver, Piers Anthony, Malcolm Gladwell, Neil Postman, anyone who writes product feature or home-decoration pieces for magazines, and, um, other writers who I dislike for either personal, political, or aesthetic reasons) doesn’t do anything useful for the world as a whole.
By contrast, I think real honest-to-god journalism is valuable, and requires a good deal of time-consuming work to do well; I was struggling to think of a sustainable system for paying journalists that didn’t compromise their ethics by making them dependent on some large corporation... so I thought about state sponsorship, which is obviously fatally flawed... Anyway, more thoughts on this sometime.]
Annnyway, so this guy suggested possible ways to help entrench music sharing into culture until we’re able to squeeze control of art out of the hands of the giant profitmongering media conglomerates. The proposal that I remember particularly is having parties where everyone brings drives and disks full of music, rips them, shares them, heads home, and comes with a new set for the next party. I’d actually recently been to something like (only more one-sided) at Jessamyn’s Fourth of July party, during which CDs were ripped continuously, adding to her already huge selection of MP3s. Seems like a good model, and I do always like practical applications to visionary whining.
Robert Durff sent me a CD for my birthday which I found fit well into what I’ve been looking for from music recently. He was surprised when I told him so, because the last thing I told him I was into was “Latin.” Which is still true, really. The bulk of the music I listen to has Latin roots, mostly because I find immersing myself in it is less irritating than immersing myself in the remaining trickle of the mainstream American rock tradition, which is so polluted with influences and demography as to be unswimmable at this point.
So. Let’s all get together and swap. Here’s what I’ve ingested over the past year; if you want some lemme know; if you know similar things I might like, tell me. Here’s reviews, which I’ve arranged according to my foraging patterns in response to record industry hysteria. Notice not one of these musical interactions involves theft, though one does involve questionable borrowing.
These are CDs I’ve actually bought in the past year:
Here’s artists I’ve copied in bulk in the past year:
Here’s copied music I’ve been passed in the past few weeks:
Here’s CDs I’ve received in the past week and have only barely listened to:
Here’s a CD I ordered and haven’t received yet:
Here’s stuff off of cassette tapes I’ve been turning into MP3s, but it probably won’t piss off the RIAA:
Here’s artists whose tapes I have had forever but haven’t listened to until recently:
Here’s artists I know who deserve mad props:
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.twistedmatrix.com/~gus.twistd/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/4
If you think Bernstein is a conspiracy theorist, you are probably being way too literal-minded. His satirical voice doesn't seem to come across as well on the albums -- I've heard this confusion from a bunch of folks who hadn't seen him live -- but this is one musician who you shouldn't conflate entirely with the narrators of his songs.
This confusion might all be explained by his fervent desire to piss off his audience (which I've seen in concert any number of times). The first time I saw Dan was when he opened for Ani DiFranco a few years ago, and he sang "Tiger Woods" (the song that begins "I've got BIG BALLS...") to start out, before this crowd of eager dykey young women. I think he was doing it just to alienate them.
"Filthy," of course, is right on target. But when did this become a bad thing?
Posted by: Roger at July 26, 2002 11:53 AM
Hey you might want to check out AmParanoia. It's fun up beat political latin fusion. And their website has dancing zapatista dolls. I thought there were spanish but from reading their website it's four people from cuba, and one from bulgaria, barcelona, and switzerland. It's good music, worth listening to even if you don't care about the politics.
Posted by: evan at August 4, 2002 4:22 PM
hello,
just randomly found your site while searching for 'pyso' on yahoo... i was in it, too (viola)... as for recordings of mr meyers pieces, you can find them online... i have a cd that was made during one of the all southern concerts when i was in jr high (with meyer conducting) that has his 'return of the dawn treader' on it. anyway, i just wanted to reach out and poke a fellow pyso alumni/meyer fan.
Posted by: bekki at December 22, 2003 4:23 AM